In the national Football League, the Manning family is royalty. Brothers Eli and Peyton space two of the league"s greatest stars, with 3 Super key rings in between them. The matchup between the Denver Broncos and new York Giants in main 2 will be one of the many talked-about games of the 2013 regular season.

You are watching: Eli and peyton manning super bowl

The 2 are similar to the world"s most well known royal brother in part respects. ~ above the soccer field, Peyton is really much Prince William, the picture of seriousness and also dignity. Eli, top top the other hand, is Prince Harry, the gunslinger who sometimes flies by the seat of his pants.


Their styles may it is in different, however it"s hard to argue v the results. Both have won the NFL"s best game, and their careers will certainly all but certainly finish with both anchored in the pro Football room of Fame.

One can"t help, in ~ this point in their corresponding careers, but do a little bit of comparing. It"s just natural. Believe me, the brothers themselves most likely do it. It"s just something the brothers do.

So, i beg your pardon one is it? wilhelm or Harry? Which brother is the Man(ning)?


*

Video pat Button


Videos you might like
According come a former teammate of Eli Manning, that answer is simple. As man Breech the CBS sports reports, former new York Giants running ago Tiki Barber believes the Eli has supplanted Peyton at the top of the Manning food chain:

The expectation was the he was never going to be Peyton. Ns remember having actually these conversations with world who watched Eli in college, saying, "He"s good, yet he"s never ever going to it is in Peyton, he"s no Peyton." guess what? i think he"s far better than Peyton. Due to the fact that of clutch. What matters in sports? It"s winning and losing. You obtain to the stage and also what do you do? Eli"s gained there and he"s won.

On some level, Barber has a point. Eli has actually experienced fairly a bit much more postseason success than his larger brother, with an 8-3 document in the playoffs matches Peyton"s 9-11 mark.

However, that comparison comes through caveats of its own. For starters, there"s the straightforward fact the Peyton has actually played in nearly twice as countless playoff games as his younger brother. Eli may have actually had much more success when he gets there, but Peyton it s okay there choose clockwork.

Then there"s the fact that football is very much a team sport. Yes, Eli has actually led fourth-quarter comebacks in both that his Super bowl victories, but brand-new York"s uncomfortable of the unbeaten new England Patriots in Super key XLII was spurred through a leading performance by large Blue"s defensive front.


If Asante Samuel doesn"t fall a game-clinching interception, and also David Tyree doesn"t make among the most remarkable captures in NFL history, climate the Giants don"t success that game. Lock did, yet to do a blanket statement that "Eli is better because that has more rings" is just nonsense.

Ben Roethlisberger has actually two rings too, however as an excellent as Roethlisberger is, no one outside of the Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback"s mommy thinks he"s much better than Peyton Manning.

We"ll give the postseason success points to Eli though. The wins that battle, yet that doesn"t typical he"s winner the war.

A look in ~ the regular-season numbers for each player, for example, sends out the momentum back in Peyton"s direction.

Even v Peyton"s shed 2011 season thrown into the equation, his numbers are considerably superior to Eli"s. He"s thrown for an ext yardage and also touchdowns per season, v fewer interceptions and a higher passer rating. Peyton has far an ext 4,000-yard seasons and also years with 30 or an ext touchdown passes.

With that said, right here come those caveats again. For numerous years the Colts were really much a happen team, if Eli"s Giants have been more focused top top defense and also running the ball. It"s not precisely surprising that Peyton"s life stats are better.

A look at the stat behind the stats sends Peyton into the lead.

According to the reverse rankings (i.e. Higher is better) from pro Football emphasis (subscription required), only once has Eli outranked Peyton among NFL quarterbacks in the last 5 years. That was in 2011, once Peyton didn"t play. In two of the last five years PFF ranked Peyton as the NFL"s optimal quarterback, including last year.


To both players" credit, only when over that stretch has each Manning ranked outside the NFL"s optimal 10 signal-callers.

What about the most essential stat that all? Wins and also losses?

Peyton has actually a far-ranging edge in the regard as well. His .688 winning percentage is over 10 points greater than Eli"s. The weighted to win percentage offered by agree Football recommendation results in a narrow gap, but the gap still exists.

It"s additionally worth note that, according to the metric, devised ago in 2009, Peyton is the winningest quarterback in the history of the national Football League.

Peyton also wins the battle for separation, personal, instance accolades. Eli may have much more rings and also two Super bowl MVP awards to Peyton"s one, yet Peyton has actually 12 pro Bowl trips to Eli"s three. Peyton has likewise been named the NFL"s Most an useful Player a record four times and also has a Comeback Player of the Year compensation on his mantle after critical year.

It"s starting to look favor Eli is walk to require one the those clutch comebacks to traction this one out.

Oh yeah, about that.

According to pro Football Reference, Peyton has actually led 49 game-winning drives in 15 seasons, or 3.27 every year. Eli, on the various other hand, has 28 such drives in ripe seasons, or 3.11 per season.

Eli, however, does reap a slight edge in fourth-quarter comebacks. In ripe NFL seasons, Eli has engineered 24 together comebacks, or 2.67 every year. Peyton"s 38 fourth-quarter comebacks in 15 year checks in slightly lower (2.53 per season).


Neither stat is a huge surprise. Peyton has led many of comeback wins, and also Eli stop the document for many fourth-quarter touchdown passes in a season with 15 in 2011.

In various other words, Barber"s assertion that Eli is more "clutch" is a myth, bolstered through the truth that two of Eli"s comebacks come in the at sight Bowl.

In fact, had Tracy Porter of the new Orleans Saints to reduce the ball in Super bowl XLIV prefer Samuel walk in Super bowl XLII, Barber would certainly have even less the a foot to stand on, yet he didn"t.

Frankly, the whole debate over i m sorry Manning is "better" is quite silly. Both players space Super bowl champions and also future hall of Famers.

It"s prefer debating the "68 Chevelle vs. The "69 Mustang. They"re both an extremely nice cars.

With that said, sports fans love to do comparisons, and also the fact that the 2 players involved in this comparison are brothers just makes it all the an ext compelling.

See more: Foods Not To Eat When On A Diet Mistakes: 6 Reasons You'Re Not Losing Weight

Once you do compare the two, however, just about every objective criteria exterior of gaudy jewelry leader to one conclusion.