The Elk River, West Virginia chemical spill of Jan. 9, 2014 has been among the most an overwhelming environmental health and wellness emergencies to take place within the United claims over the past decade, and also it has actually garnered significant national attention over the course of the past three months. The event arisen when the freedom Industries pour out poured 10,000 gallons of toxicity 4-methylcyclohexane methanol (MCHM), and far-ranging quantities of polyglycol ether right into one of West Virginia’s most crucial sources the public drink water, leaving 300,000 human being in nine counties (roughly 16 percent of the state’s total population) there is no drinking water.

You are watching: Elk river west virginia chemical spill


Dr. Rahul Gupta, health and wellness Officer and also Executive manager of the Kanawha-Charleston health Department

Dr. Rahul Gupta, health and wellness Officer and also Executive director of the Kanawha-Charleston health Department, is one public health and wellness official who has gone to the forefront of restore efforts throughout the state. In the adhering to interview, Dr. Gupta discusses his experiences end the food of the past couple of months with Justin Snair, senior Program Analyst for an important Infrastructure and also Environmental security at

Q: can you please define your endure coordinating with other agencies end the food of her community’s restore from this spill, and who were her partners?

A: Thanks for your ongoing interest in, and support of, our ongoing initiatives to assist our neighborhood recover indigenous what has been a very trying ordeal.

The Elk river Chemical Spill was a major environmental wellness emergency, it affected hundreds of countless people and also had a wide ranging impact across my local community and also state. Such a large drinking water contamination event is practically unheard that in this country history. In attempting to recoup from this crisis, us have operated with a really wide perform of local, state, federal, and private agencies and also organizations to name: coordinates our response. These incorporate the Kanawha-Charleston board of Health, Kanawha county Commission, Kanawha ar Emergency Management, the mayor of Charleston, the City the Charleston Emergency Management, leaderships of several various other townships, other local public wellness departments, the West Virginia department of wellness & human Resources, the nationwide Guard, the Governor’s office, the West Virginia Secretary that State’s Office, ours state legislature, the West Virginia Poison control Center, our local, national, and international media, the workplaces of both of our U.S. Senators (Joe Manchin and also Jay Rockefeller), as well as our U.S. Representatives (Shelly an ext Capito and also Nick Joe Rahall) and numerous various other organizations.

Hopefully, the size of this list gives some limit for just how big of an initiative the an answer and recovery process from this spill has been, and how numerous organizations and public officials throughout the state and federal government have had actually to occupational together to assist us relocate our ar forward.

Q: i beg your pardon of this partners walk you rely upon the most, and what gaps in her collaborative efforts did girlfriend notice?

A: Since these kinds of huge emergencies happen very rarely, plenty of of my closest partnerships were developed out of necessity over the food of our response. In an unmatched measure, governor Tomblin bespeak the national Guard to assist the Kanawha-Charleston health Department to respond to this public wellness emergency. Together a result, i worked closely with Adjutant basic James Hoyer of the West Virginia nationwide Guard to support 40-50 nationwide Guard troops in ~ the Kanawha-Charleston wellness Department. This troops have actually been from approximately six various states. For a duration of days, these men and also women the the nationwide Guard have assisted our employee in reopening schools, businesses, and other establishments across the county. Based upon the outcomes of our fantastic working relationship and highly reliable partnership, a rapid an answer team has been formulated consisting of health and wellness department sanitarians, the national Guard, and also community institution officials. The function of this rapid solution team is to investigate, answers to, and also take action towards any kind of school complaints across the county for a duration of numerous weeks walking forward.

The Kanawha-Charleston wellness Department has actually also proactively worked through Metro 911 to carry out technical and also subject matter aid for the various local emergency administration agencies, and also to assist in water distribution. The wellness Department served as a water circulation site, an organizer for such events, and also played a critical role in ensuring the delivery of the water to handicap populations.

As because that the second component of her question—gaps which we noticed? It was clear from the very beginning that our response that we need to significantly re-think our communication protocols walking forward. We very first learned that the chemical pour out from media reports and also widespread windy complaints. This is clear problematic because that any variety of reasons, however it is especially daunting to administer accurate and timely info to our constituents when we are discovering of an occasion for the an initial time through the exact same sources and also channels that they are.

I speak at length about these challenges over the course of several main testimonies i beg your pardon I provided to the state legislature, and also multiple provisions have been since added to Senate bill 373 (SB 373), a bill recently signed into law by governor Tomblin which aims at rectifying problems identified by the freedom Industries spill.

During public health emergencies, local health departments in West Virginia are required to submit reports and requests v two separate occurrence command structures. We have one set of reports that must be sent out to the ar emergency operations center (EOC)/incident command, that will then submit this information to the State EOC. We have actually another set of reports which we are required to send to the West Virginia room of wellness & human being Resources center for danger Preparedness, Public health and wellness Incident Command. This information is also processed and sent off to the State EOC. The type of repetitive processes consume our already restricted resources i beg your pardon are especially important to conserve during times that emergencies.

Q: You pointed out that you provided a variety of recommendations to the West Virginia State legislative branch which to be subsequently embraced and imposed in SB 373. Space there any recommendations of particular importance i beg your pardon you were happy to see had in the last legislation?

A: I to be asked to administer several testimonies, as well as written documentation, and also other guidance come the West Virginia State Legislature i m sorry was very interested in occurring a strong legislative response to the liberty Industries spill. ~ above a really broad level, the bulk of mine testimony concentrated on problems which ns have already mentioned here—I specifically advocated for an ext effective inter- and also intra-agency communications, a larger duty for local wellness departments in water safety, and also the consist of of long-term clinical monitoring. Unfortunately, there is a far-reaching lack of an important public health and wellness infrastructure in West Virginia and altering this dynamic is a long term goal which i hope my testimony will start to acquire the round rolling on. SB 373 has actually been signed into law newly by governor Tomblin with numerous of mine recommendations implemented in the final bill, therefore I believe that points are slowly progressing in a optimistic direction.

Q: What other essential corrections carry out you feel need to be in location in order to mitigate/ much better manage a comparable crisis in the future?

A: SB 373 was a great start below at the state level, however West Virginia still demands to embrace the 2008 references made by the united state Chemical security Board adhering to the Bayer CropScience explosion in i beg your pardon two world were killed. Ns am likewise working together a member the a federal Advisory panel convened by city council Manchin to aid introduce brand-new legislative options at the federal level in the United claims Congress. This process is ongoing. However, it is vital to emphasize that this particular event has carried forth two crucial national problems of public wellness significance which room not only minimal to West Virginia: drinking water protections and also reform the the toxic Substances control Act. Public wellness agencies and organizations need to better understand and also assist in shaping legislation and also policies top top both of these fronts.

Q: us have debated a big number the obstacles and procedural roadblocks/gaps which you have faced over the past several month in attempting come respond to this crisis. In her mind, what to be the three difficulties that stand out the most to you end the course of this crisis?

A: I would begin with the difficulties which we had in obtaining accurate and timely information from state and federal level stakeholders. As the level of federal government most proximate to the people, we enjoy a deep level of trust and also faith through our communities and as a result they meant us come be aware of and also immediately interact any developments in one open and transparent manner. Us were additionally in the uncomfortable position of explaining come the ar a number of conflicting statements native the various entities affiliated in the recovery efforts about the safety of the water because that drinking and also general usage at various points follow me the way. Because that example, there were times as soon as the water was claimed safe for everyone yet 2 days later guidance was changed for pregnant women. Furthermore, once water was claimed safe, water circulation was terminated. A couple of days later, water distribution was resumed while all at once claiming that the insanity water was safe to drink. We additionally had numerous difficulties in encouraging state and federal agencies to actually construct the scientific research to support our own assertions along the way, which often served to compound this problem of trying to explain conflicting reports come a generally confused and increasingly irritable public.

Q: Transitioning far from ours conversation that the wider legislative and also regulatory issues, can you re-superstructure what you have personally learned from this crisis which will help you to far better serve your neighborhood as a regional public wellness official in the future?

A: This dilemm has made that even an ext apparent the it is crucial to repeatedly earn and also maintain the public’s trust and also confidence. We at the Kanawha-Charleston wellness Department have actually been fortunate to be thought about one of the most trusted public agencies during this crisis, and also our constituents have had a far-ranging amount that faith and trust in the information and guidance which we have noted them with.

As a general take away i would add that local public health must constantly make its decisions based on great science, and not be fear to it is in upfront and also honest once adequate science is unavailable. I additionally believe that extr staff training and education are essential in several locations including the psychological aspects of emergency response, and the usage of society media, including, but not necessarily limited to, ideal practices in time of an emergency.

Q: ns think you carry up critical point in your last response: to this suggest we have primarily focused on the challenges which girlfriend have faced as a regional public health and wellness official trying come respond come this crisis. I think it’s also important to know this event from the perspective of your impacted community members—what has actually their suffer been favor over the food of this ordeal, and what major challenges have they faced in adapting come this disaster? What has actually been the biggest challenge which your ar has faced as a result of the spill?

A: Because us are part of our community, the health department’s frustrations and the community’s disappointed were very similar. There has actually been a basic lack of trust in the water supply. In ~ one point “safe” ended up being a four letter word. There space innumerable problems connected with merely not having actually a clear expertise whether or no the neighborhood water supply is safe—this results general hygiene, nutrition, it causes economic disruptions as the community is required to expend additional resources in securing non-contaminated sources of water, etc. Schools and local government agencies can additionally experience disturbances in service—the difficulties run the gambit. When this is all compounded by a lack of good scientific information/ conflicting scientific details from the experts, and also varying levels of activity and an answer from the state and also federal government in attempting to respond to this widespread crisis, over there is a organic increase in frustration v governmental agencies and a ns of public trust in general.

Q: deserve to you administer any more clarification or examples of what you average by “explaining to the ar conflicting declaration from these entities?” exactly how did you deal with these?

A: The spill emerged on Jan. 9. Top top Jan.13, it was announced through state and federal partners that the water was safe to consume after the flushing process. In the late evening that Jan. 15, info was released from the CDC cautioning pregnant women to continue to use bottle water. There to be a variety of well-regarded specialists that publicly disagreed through the methodology the was being offered to check the as whole safety of our water supply, and some additionally challenged the CDC’s screening levels for MCHM. On Feb. 5, in a push conference, CDC officials declared that the water to be ‘appropriate’ come drink. The usage of words ‘appropriate’ irritable my community and also the media which was currently growing significantly dissatisfied by the state and also federal response to the spill, and also so there was a cultivation sense of unrest about whether or not it made feeling to to trust what was being stated at any level of government about the actual security of our water. While this push conference to be ongoing, kids were being required to hospital from colleges in ambulance as result of ‘odor’ related problems in the water. The optics that the occasions that work was simply terrifying to the public and also it motivated a cascade of occasions where we began to get multiple school complaints that water contamination worries each day. Then, five days later, several skilled witnesses could not state conclusively the our water was in truth safe in main testimony before a congressional committee. Likewise during this time, another locally-based West Virginia scientist asserted that he had found far-reaching quantities of formaldehyde in the water and some state officials publicly disagreed v him triggering another public controversy.

As the only unit of government public health people trusted in ~ this time, it ended up being our responsibility to try to describe each and every one of the statements. This has regularly been complicated while we have actually simultaneously test to maintain the rapidly eroding trust of the people in their government.

Q: just how is your recovery progressing? space the challenges which girlfriend are dealing with at your local level the same difficulties the state and region is facing?

A: Because of the level the mistrust, the general public is sluggish to return to using the water. Inspection data from the time of the spill till March 1 mirrors that less than 5 percent of the population are drinking or food preparation with our neighborhood water, and also approximately 20 percent room not using the water for any kind of purpose. There has actually been a an additional wave the health results after the flushing which has additional exacerbated the frustrations of a very anxious and suspicious community. There has actually been little in the means of resources support by exterior organizations to evaluate the population health impacts of the spill. Also the regulatory fixes that have been happen in SB 373 space problematic in the they perform not come with added funding for security the wellness effects. Every one of this way that we are finding ourselves in a never-ending response mode.

See more: This Girl Who Does At&Amp;T Commercials, Why It Happens

Complaints pertained to the water have actually progressively decreased. However, over there is seemingly another mini-crisis every day in one of two people the schools, or with foam in the river, etc. It seems as though every day us have remained in a state of consistent crisis since Jan. 9, and also we room unsure of as soon as things will certainly return ago to ‘normal.’ for example, the group of independent researchers hired by the Governor v the West Virginia Tap assessment Project recently reported the their screening level recommendations for the chemical MCHM to be 8 times much more stringent the recommended through the CDC. Additionally, castle reported the the ten residences they performed tests on uncovered to still contain a joint webinar top top April 22 to comment on the duties of regional public health, toxicity control, and also public health and wellness laboratory public representative in the response; to reflect ~ above the challenges, systems, and also practices that resulted in the incident; and also discuss means to improve upon future responses and prevent similar incidents indigenous occurring. Register for the webinar now.