video game of Thrones: Why The Books’ ending Will Still it is in Controversial video game of Thrones suffered a an excellent backlash for its ending - while George R.R. Martin"s ASOIAF publications will be better, they"ll still be controversial.

You are watching: End of game of thrones book


Game that Thrones finishing George R R martin Bran distinguishable Daenerys Targaryen
The ending to Game that Thrones showed divisive, come say the least, yet there"s reason to believe the conclusion come George R.R. Martin"s A track of Ice and also Fire book collection will likewise be controversial. Game of Thrones is one of the biggest TV shows of all time, and also its an initial four periods in specific were acclaimed by critics and also viewers (both those who"d review the books and those who hadn"t). The trouble for showrunners David Benioff and D.B. Weiss was the they were conveniently catching-up with and also subsequently overcome the resource material, together Martin has continually struggled to write The Winds of Winter (and tho has another book early after that).


There to be a noticeable transition in storytelling when Game that Thrones overtook A song of Ice and also Fire around season 5, shifting much more from Martin"s character-driven format to a an ext fast-paced plot-driven narrative. While that didn"t instantly lead to significant issues (though season 5 is amongst its worst), it did finish up producing a butterfly effect, as the transforms made then meant a truncated, quicker finishing than many would"ve liked.

Related: What To intend From The Winds of Winter

This all involved a head with Game that Thrones season 8, i beg your pardon wrapped points up in just six episodes. There was an enormous backlash, including waves that criticism and also even petitions to re-do the show, and also Game that Thrones has end up being the internet"s new punching bag for negative endings. While several of the objections were precious (and others much less so), the collection not only took some facets from the books, however highlighted that as soon as Martin does complete his series, there will be some disappointed readers.


Game that Thrones Finale Jon go North
While the is tough to know with 100% certainty what Game of Thrones" finishing took indigenous Martin"s books besides King Bran (which has already been shown as a plot suggest the writer told the showrunners about), that is likely that much of what happened in "The iron Throne" will additionally play the end in the books. On peak of Bran"s coronation, it"s fairly easy come imagine Tyrion as soon as again being named the Hand of the King, this time v a greater sense of irony to him landing the role. It"s additionally easy to imagine the devastation of the iron Throne itself being from the psychic of Martin, offered his love that both symbolism and also of happen things full circle throughout history.


Quite how Daenerys dies (though she is most likely to) remains open up for much debate, yet the idea of her many controversial moment - the damage of King"s Landing - happening in the publications is a reasonable assumption to make. There"s to be plenty that setup on the web page for such a turn, and with the plot currently suggestion 2 Targaryens are going to it is in vying because that the stole Throne, then possibly the most likely take will be that she destroys the in what"s effectively a new Dance that the Dragons against Aegon (or fAegon) Targaryen. Game that Thrones never consisted of that character, yet it"s fair to guess that they nonetheless took the id of Daenerys" turn and also fiery reign and also ran v it in their very own story.


The fates of the Starks beyond Bran are rather up in the wait too. Jon snow going back to (and beyond) the wall feels about as installation an finishing as is possible for him, and again the sort of thing Martin would certainly dream increase (not just due to the fact that it"s a large link between the end of Game the Thrones and also Lord that the Rings, cementing Jon together the story"s Frodo, no its Aragorn). Sansa judgment the north from Winterfell additionally feels likely, those there"s a question of even if it is it"ll be together Queen or merely Warden, because the problem of independence, when pertinent, may subside provided her brother is the ruler. Arya is a bit of a wildcard in all of this, but her roaming free is well established by her arc already (and her direwolf), therefore her leave from Westeros could also have been a martin idea.


Related: Game of Thrones: exactly how The finishing Will Be various In The Books

A track of ice cream & Fire"s finishing Will it is in Controversial



With many of the destinations likely to match-up (albeit with some various journeys there), then it feels unpreventable that the finishing to A track of Ice and also Fire will certainly be controversial. The backlash won"t complement that received by Game the Thrones, no least since the audience because that the novel series is smaller, less vocal than, and simply features differently to that for a TV show millions and millions the people roughly the human being are the town hall simultaneously. However nonetheless, controversial it will certainly be. Much in the same way Game that Thrones was constantly likely to be divisive to an extent, there"s nearly no means to end this massive, long-running, much-hyped story the pleases everybody.


Aside native that, the truth that it will certainly contain part very similar elements way that the will cause some that the same division. There may be part of the fanbase hope for completely different outcomes, and also when lock don"t happen, the will cause disappointment. And also while Martin has actually done a much better job the laying the foundations, the substantial swings that are seemingly to plan - most specifically Daenerys" turn, Bran ending up being King, and also what may happen between Jaime and Cersei (though your deaths will likely happen earlier) - space going to be divisive no issue what, because the very idea of them is, especially when someone like Dany has actually such an military of faithful fans who"ll refuse come accept any such knavish switch.


There are additionally signs that there"ll it is in at the very least a partial transition in style and also tone because that the final entries in A track of Ice and Fire. While the books have long included some aspects of fear (and plenty of weirdness), that need to ramp up substantially when factoring in the increased function of the Others together Martin builds to The long Night (which will need to play the end differently, provided the absence of Night King in the novels), and whatever Eldritch terrors Euron Greyjoy may end up pass about, which may be a jarring change for some.

And when Game the Thrones systematized things also much, the publications have maybe the opposite problem: Martin has actually spun off into so plenty of different directions, complying with every breadcrumb trail under narrative cul-de-sacs, that the scope provides it challenging to imagine how whatever in play have the right to possibly coalesce. As soon as combining the sheer load of expectation with several of the plot twists and advancements that are ostensibly promised by the show"s own conclusion, climate it"s tough to see a method that over there won"t be division when the final book in the series, A Dream the Spring, comes to a close.


Related: Game that Thrones" Finale Was good (& The Only way To finish The Show)

Why ASOIAF"s ending Will quiet Be much better Than video game of Thrones


White Walkers and also George RR martin in game of Thrones
While there will certainly be sections of the fanbase who will it is in unhappy, disappointed, and perhaps even angry over just how A song of Ice and Fire ends, it"s additionally extremely likely that the ending of the books will be far better than Game that Thrones. That"s not necessarily a punch on Game of Thrones" finale either, which, despite its countless detractors, did eventually feel narratively and also thematically satisfying, and made countless of the ideal emotional choices. Instead, it"s more a testimony to the much much more detailed civilization that young name has developed on the page, and also that, ultimately, this is his vision he"s seeing through to the end, rather than some hybrid the it.


Although fans might feel a sense of frustration with just how long boy name is acquisition to write The Winds the Winter (never mind A Dream the Spring, and aside from the fact he doesn"t fan anybody anything), his more careful and patient plotting have to pay dividends in the lengthy run. The best criticism that Game the Thrones" ending - and also the one it"s very difficult to defend - is that it was rushed, i m sorry goes throughout the final two periods (if not more). And also while martin does have actually his own faults as a writer, there"s much more chance of warm Pie claiming the steel Throne or HBO remaking the entire series than over there is the him gift accused that rushing the ending.

See more: Game Of Thrones Season 7 Episode 6 Online Stream : Watch Online


Furthermore, there is the previously mentioned fact the the controversial elements will make more sense top top the page. Not only is that because some the the situations will be different, but since of the format of the books, i beg your pardon charts the storylines from details POV characters. Just how much better may Daenerys" fiery damage of King"s Landing be, because that example, if we acquire to completely experience her and Tyrion"s thoughts and perspectives ~ above it? just how much more satisfying will certainly Bran"s time together the Three-Eyed crow be once audiences have the right to truly understand who and also what he is? this decisions will certainly be divisive still, but Martin is a grasp of setups and payoffs, and also that"s what he"ll deliver in A track of Ice and also Fire"s ending that Game the Thrones didn"t completely manage for everyone.