The quest for the historical Paul

James Tabor considers Biblical and also external account of the apostle


This article was initially published in November 2012 top top Dr. James Tabor’s renowned Taborblog, a site that discusses and also reports top top “‘All things biblical’ indigenous the Hebrew bible to at an early stage Christianity in the roman World and Beyond.” Bible background Daily republished the short article with consent that the author. Visit Taborblog or scroll down to check out a short bio that James Tabor.

You are watching: Evidence of paul outside the bible

What can we reliably know around Paul and also how can we recognize it? as is the situation with Jesus, this is not straightforward question. Historians have actually been affiliated in what has actually been called the “Quest because that the historic Jesus” because that the past one hundred and seventy-five years, assessing and sifting v our sources, trying to identify what we have the right to reliably say about him. as it happens, the pursuit for the historical Paul began practically simultaneously, inaugurated by the German scholar Ferdinand Christian Baur. Baur placed his finger squarely on the problem: There space four different “Pauls” in the new Testament, not one, and each is quite distinct from the others. New Testament scholars today are usually agreed ~ above this point.


*
*
*
Dr. James Tabor is Chair that the department of spiritual Studies in ~ the university of north Carolina in ~ Charlotte wherein he is professor that Christian beginnings and old Judaism. Due to the fact that earning his Ph.D. In ~ the college of Chicago in 1981, Tabor has combined his work-related on ancient texts with considerable field work-related in archaeology in Israel and also Jordan, including work at Qumran, Sepphoris, Masada and Wadi el-Yabis in Jordan. End the previous decade he has teamed up v with Shimon Gibson to excavate the “John the Baptist” cave at Suba, the “Tomb the the Shroud” discovered in 2000, Mt Zion and, in addition to Rami Arav, he has been affiliated in the re-exploration the two burial places in east Talpiot consisting of the controversial “Jesus tomb.” Tabor’s latest book is Paul and Jesus: how the Apostle changed Christianity. You can find links to all of Dr. Tabor’s internet pages, books and projects in ~ jamestabor.com.

Notes

The pursuit was offered both its history and its surname by Albert Schweiter, whose groundbreaking book, released in 1906 v the nondescript German title, Von Reimarus zu Wrede (from Reimarus come Wrede), was given the much more provocative title in English, The pursuit of the historic Jesus, interpreted by william Montgomery (London: Adam & Charles Black, 1910).

The start of the modern Jesus quest is generally dated to roughly 1835 with the publishing of David Strauss’s Life the Jesus. The complete German title of Strauss’s work, Das Leben Jesu kritisch bearbeitet (Tübingen: 1835-1836) was released in English as The Life the Jesus, Critically Examined (3 vols., London, 1846), interpreted by George Eliot, the penname of brother novelist mary Ann Evans. Baur’s significant work, Paulus, der Apostel Jesu Christi, sein Leben und Wirken, seine Briefe und seine Lehre (Paul the Apostle of Jesus Christ: His Life and Works, His Letters and His Teaching) was released in1845. Strauss to be a college student of Baur at the university of Tübingen.

most recently, Marcus Borg and also John Dominic Crossan, The first Paul: Reclaiming the Radical Visionary Behind the Church’s Conservative Icon (New York: HarperOne, 2009). A more conservative, however nonetheless critical treatment relying more on the letters of Paul 보다 the book of plot is that of Jerome Murphy-O’Conner, Paul: A vital Life (New York: Oxford university Press, 1996).

one English copy that the new Testament, Revised standard Version, with message only and no note or references, runs 284 pages total. The thirteen letters attributed to Paul, plus the book of Acts, add up to 109 pages of the total—just over one-third.

view Bart Ehrman’s an introduction analysis “In the wake of the Apostle: The Deutero-Pauline and Pastoral Epistles,” in The brand-new Testament: A Historical advent to the beforehand Christian Writings, 4th ed. (New York: Oxford college Press, 2008), pp. 272-394.

“Chester Beatty Papyri” in Anchor holy bible Dictionary, Vol. 1 (New York: Doubleday, 1992), pp. 901-903.

Not only was the ingredient of together speeches usual in Greek literary histories, it was expected. Thucydides, in his History the the Peloponnesian war, says that he created speeches according to “what was referred to as for in each situation” ( 1. 22. 2). Josephus, a modern of the writer of Acts, is a prime example; check out Henry Cadbury, The do of Luke-Acts (New York: Macmillan Company, 1927), and Arthur J. Droge and James D. Tabor, A Noble Death: Suicide and also Martyrdom among Christians and also Jews in Antiquity (New York: HarperCollins, 1992), pp. 53-112.

the is feasible that Paul was once married since he states he progressed within Judaism past his peers. Jewish men his age would typically marry; not to marry would be taken into consideration abnormal. In his letters he speaks of the “loss of every things” and additionally refers to a case where an “unbelieving wife” could leave one who has actually joined his movement, so the is feasible he is alluding come his own personal situation since he says the brothers or sister, so abandoned, have to not feeling obligated come heed Jesus’ teaching that there can be no divorce for any cause (Philippians 3:7; 1 Corinthians 7:12-16).

The letter the James and Jude can be exception though countless scholars concern if these two brothers the Jesus were component of the Twelve and others inquiries the authenticity that the letters themselves. Few scholars think about the letter of 1 and also 2 Peter as written by Peter. 1 Peter, in particular, is how amazing “Pauline” in tone and content and fits naught we understand of Peter based on much more reliable sources—including Paul’s actual letters. The letter of John room not from man the fisherman, among the Twelve, yet from a later on John, periodically referred to as “John the Elder,” who stayed in Asia boy (see Eusebius, Church History 3.39.4-7).

Pirke Avot 2. 3.

Jerome, De Virus Illustribus (PL 23, 646).

watch Jerome Murphy-O’Conner, Paul: A critical Life, pp. 1-5. The translate into “ambassador,” discovered in the Revised conventional Version, is conjectural, with no manuscript support. That assumes the misspelling that the Greek native “ambassador” (presbeutes), together “elder” (presbytes), yet “elder” is the analysis in all our manuscripts. The brand-new Revised traditional Version and brand-new Jerusalem bible correctly have “elder.”

Josephus, Jewish War 7. 263-265. Josephus mentions john of Gischala often in his history of the revolt.

view Digest 48. 6-7, a compendium that Roman legislation in The Digest of Justinian, ed. T. Mommsen, interpreted by A. Watson (Philadelphia: Pennsylvania State university Press, 1985).

A comparison of mark 13, sometimes dubbed the “Synoptic Apocalypse,” or the “Little Apocalypse,” v Luke 21, i beg your pardon is the author’s rewriting of Mark, one sees how the “end of the age” is indefinitely extended and no much longer tied come the Jewish-Roman battle of A.D. 66-74.

translate into by Wilhelm Schneemelcher in Edgar Hennecke’s New testimony Apocrypha, edited by wilhelm Schneemelcher, interpreted by R. McL. Wilson, volume 2 (Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1965), pp. 353.

Ignatius, Philippians 3:2.

See more: Goliath Roller Coaster Six Flags Over Georgia ), Goliath Front Row (Hd Pov) Six Flags Over Georgia

see Eusebius, Church History 2. 14. 5-6 and also 3.1.2, who says he is relying on Origen, one early third century Christian theologian.