Continued inaction from conference on work-family policies, including the existing lack of access to affordable child care and comprehensive paid family and also medical leave, costs workers $31.9 billion in lost wages annually.

You are watching: Family policy issues in the news

Two ladies who have actually been living in homeless shelters after struggling to find jobs that would certainly cover the price of child care wait v their youngsters for the bus in Atlanta, December 2015. (Getty/Michael S. Williamson/The Washington Post)

A typical excuse given for the lack of work-family support policies in the United says is the they would certainly be nice come have however are “extremely costly.” This simplistic approach to expertise the fiscal and also economic impact of work-family policies—looking in ~ the complete cost of benefits paid the end in isolation of just how they interact with other programs and also benefits—ignores the numerous ways that these species of policy interventions can save money in various other areas. For example, the i of the federal Employees Paid leave Act, which will carry out up come 12 weeks of payment parental leave to qualifying commonwealth employees, is anticipated to conserve the federal federal government $50 million in expenses related to employee turnover. Potential savings to businesses or other government programs are not the only components that must be taken into account when assessing the true price of work-family plan supports, however. The existing narrative generally additionally ignores the reality that separation, personal, instance workers and also families—especially working family members of color, low-wage workers, unmarried functioning parents, and other breakable workers—are currently experiencing direct hits to their income as a an outcome of not having actually these plans in place. The longer Congress and also the Trump administration refuse to act on work-family policies, the greater the costs to family members will proceed to climb.

Previous CAP analysis using data from 2005 v 2015 found that, every year, workers in the United states were losing out on at the very least an approximated $28.9 exchange rate in wages due to a absence of accessibility to affordable child care and comprehensive paid family and also medical leave. This contained $8.3 billion in shed wages due to a absence of boy care and $20.6 billion in lost wages as result of a absence of access to paid family and also medical leave. These costs have only boosted in the years since.

Using an ext recent data, native 2009 with 2018, our analysis finds that the full estimated expense to workers as result of a lack of access to affordable child treatment and considerable paid family and also medical leave has actually increased come $31.9 exchange rate in yearly lost wages.* (see Table 1) This consists of $9.4 billion in lost wages as result of child care problems, which incorporates those who we estimate room unemployed due to a lack of access to child care and those that either space temporarily or generally working part time due to difficultly accessing son care. Together Congress stops working to act, workers and their families additionally lose an estimated linked $22.5 billion in incomes each year as result of a absence of payment family and also medical leave.


Both men and women stand to advantage from work-family supports

Although data limitations prevent united state from analyzing these estimates by race or ethnicity, it is clear that men and women carry out not feel the impacts evenly, nor room the gendered patterns consistent across different varieties of caregiving needs. Although guys consistently earn higher wages when compared with women, men as a entirety lose under wages concerned a lack of access to son care, payment parental leave, and also paid family members caregiving leave. (see Table 2) functioning women shed an approximated $8.8 billion in potential wages because of the challenges linked with finding child care as well as second $11.6 billion due to lack of accessibility to payment family and also medical leave.


It is not surprising that women experience significantly greater lost earnings than men, together it has actually repeatedly been presented that women take on the majority of family caregiving responsibilities contrasted with men—even when they also work for pay. Women are much more likely than males to report the they space unemployed because of child treatment reasons or after having actually a baby. Moreover, in spite of the reality that ladies earn much less than men, top top average, lock report much greater aggregate lost wages as a an outcome of their significant caregiving responsibilities. Females are likewise much more likely than males to take parental leaving after the bear or fostering of a child. And also they are much more likely to take household caregiving leaving to provide care come a seriously ill or injured loved one—all of which outcomes in much higher aggregate shed wages.

However, men are much an ext likely to report taking unpaid or partially paid temporary special needs leave to attend to their very own serious health concerns. As a result, men shed out on more than twin the aggregate lost incomes of women in the category. When work-family plans are often explained as women’s issues, this data show that the need for comprehensive paid family and also medical leaving is experienced across gender lines. In fact, the lack of nationwide attention come the require for paid temporary impairment leave has a much larger financial effect on males than the does ~ above women. A lack of access to temporary impairment leave is by far the best driver of shed wages because that workers across the concerns analyzed in this column, highlighting the prominence of taking a considerable approach to paid leave.

Despite existing inaction in Washington, an extensive policy suggest exist

While the Trump administration may case that the is helping working families through that policies, the hard truth remains that households are losing at least $31.9 exchange rate in wages each year as result of a absence of accessibility to affordable child care and comprehensive paid family and also medical leave. These estimates do no even begin to record the extr effects the a lack of work-family supports deserve to have—ranging from enhanced reliance on various other public benefits to irreversible losses in future wages and retirement security. While the administration and republic in Congress may pay lip organization to work-family support policies, their actions continuously fall brief of what working families need. Incomplete or harmful paid leave proposals that overlook the need for short-term disability and family caregiving pipeline while raiding Social defense or various other programs that households depend on; tax incentives that fail to encourage companies to act; and endless roundtables and listening sessions the never lead to serious policy transforms are no the answer.

Strong existing legislation such together the Child treatment for Working families Act would help to support working family members by limiting what castle pay for child care to 7 percent the their family members income—meeting the U.S. Department of Health and also Human Services’ definition of affordability. The bill would additionally increase son care options with a details focus ~ above nontraditional hours and rise compensation and benefits for the early childhood workforce. In addition, the household Act is the just proposal at this time before Congress that would develop a an extensive paid family and also medical leaving program based upon proven techniques from effective state programs. It would create a nationwide program to carry out up to 12 mainly of paid leave to employees to treatment for a brand-new child or a seriously ill or injured family members member or to address their own serious health and wellness concern.

The expense of inaction will certainly only continue to rise over time till common-sense policies are enacted to ensure that working families are may be to do ends accomplish while caring for themselves and also their love ones.

See more: Famous People Who Are In Scientology, 70 Celebrity Scientologists

Sarah jane Glynn is a an elderly fellow at the center for American Progress.

*For more information on how these estimates were derived, please view Appendix A of the authors’ previous report, “The price of Work-Family plan Inaction: Quantifying the prices Families currently Face together a an outcome of lacking U.S. Work-Family Policies.”