Roosevelt clashed with members of the can be fried Court, consisting of Chief justice Charles Evans Hughes (center, prior row), over his new Deal policies.

You are watching: Franklin roosevelt appointed six additional justices of the supreme cour

Getty photos

Less than 3 years after president Franklin D. Roosevelt enacted the brand-new Deal, the sweeping economic programs draft to help the unified States recover from the great Depression, the can be fried Court started overturning an essential aspects the Roosevelt"s legislation.

"When the very first New Deal situation reached the supreme Court in January 1935, the court struck under a an essential piece of the nationwide Recovery Administration, the centerpiece that plans to get the country out the the Depression," explains historian Jeff Shesol, whose brand-new book explores tensions in between FDR and also the high court. "And native that allude on, for the following year and a half, the court basically struck down all of the central pillars the the new Deal. ... By the end of the hatchet that ended in 1936, one columnist said that the reminded that of a Shakespeare tragedy: at the end of the play, the stage is strewn with dead bodies. Those dead bodies were the brand-new Deal programs."

In Supreme Power: Franklin Roosevelt vs. The supreme Court, Shesol examines Roosevelt"s frustration through the conservative righteousness branch throughout his administration -- and his attempt, shortly after his re-election in 1936, to pack the can be fried Court with as numerous as six additional justices.

Even prior to Roosevelt took office in 1933, he knew that a dispute with the high court was inevitable. The court had actually been a powerfully conservative force in American life due to the fact that the early 1880s, and at the moment it included members such as Justice Pierce Butler, that opposed the commonwealth regulation of wall surface Street, and Justice George Sutherland, who frequently battled gradual legislation as a senator throughout the presidency of wilhelm Howard Taft.

Even much more troubling to Roosevelt to be the reality that nobody of the justices had actually been appointed throughout his an initial term -- and also most that them had actually served for well end a decade.

In addition, Shesol says, one idea to be floating around street corners and editorial pages that the can be fried Court shouldn"t necessarily have the critical word on constitutional matters.


"Some said that conference ought to be able to overrule the can be fried Court," he explains. "By a two-thirds vote, congress should be able to overturn any type of ruling that the supreme Court, essentially making congress the last word on the Constitution and also not the can be fried Court."

FDR saw Court, not Constitution, as The Problem

Roosevelt, however, didn"t endorse the ideas that congress or the American public should have the ability to override the supreme Court.

"He didn"t think it to be practical," says Shesol. "It take away a an extremely long time, usually, come amend the structure ... Enough to readjust the reality in the country. But secondly, and also this is really essential in expertise why Roosevelt packed the court, the didn"t see any kind of kind that contradiction in between the Constitution and the brand-new Deal. He didn"t think there to be anything in the Constitution the prevented him from doing what he required to do. The difficulty as he witnessed it was not the Constitution; it was the conservative on that certain Supreme Court. Therefore what might you possibly do about them? for this reason that"s just how he involved the idea of packing it."

More ~ above the can be fried Court

for Decades, Stevens Molded High Court Rulings April 9, 2010

Roosevelt"s idea was the for any type of justice over the period of 70 who refused to retire, the president could appoint a new justice come sit alongside the existing justice and do his work.

"If the setup passed and no one retired, Roosevelt would instantly obtain to appoint six brand-new liberal judge to the can be fried Court," describes Shesol. "Because he couldn"t press the conservatives off the court, that thought, "Well, at least I can outnumber them." and also what most people didn"t realize then or today is the this is completely constitutional. There"s nothing in the Constitution that sets the number of justices in ~ nine. The Constitution says nothing around how countless justices there are."

Blowback to FDR"s Plan

When Congress and members that Roosevelt"s management found out about the president"s idea, they did no react well.

"Remarkably, man Nance Garner, that was Roosevelt"s vice president, went ago with him come Capitol Hill, was standing in the fine of the Senate and, together the setup was review aloud to the senators, Garner organized his nose and also gestured thumbs down," claims Shesol.

See more: Frank Gore Signing With Jets, Per Agent Drew Rosenhaus, Frank Gore To Sign One

Meanwhile, a number of Supreme Court Justices considered resigning en masse if the setup went through.

"Both chef Justice Charles Evans Hughes and also Justice Harlan Fiske rock were passionate to testify against the arrangement before Congress," claims Shesol. "Ultimately, they chose that this would certainly really lug the court too directly into the political controversy. Yet they both worked really hard and an extremely effectively behind the scene to lug the arrangement down."

Hughes wrote an open up letter come the Senate deconstructing the plan, i m sorry Shesol says had actually a terrible effect. In addition, the court suddenly started upholding several parts of the new Deal, consisting of minimum wage and the nationwide Labor connections Act. And also then justice Willis van Devanter, a conservative, retired from the court, providing Roosevelt the opportunity to choose his very own justice. Shortly thereafter, Roosevelt"s proposition died.

Shesol states the assembly of the existing Supreme Court points out several of the troubles with Roosevelt"s argument.

"Age go not define ideology," that says. "Even though Roosevelt looked at what he referred to as the "nine old men of the supreme Court" and also suggested that the enlarge justices were falling the end of touch with reality, the oldest justice on that court in the 1930s to be Brandeis, the an excellent liberal justice. And also this was stated with glee with many of Roosevelt"s opponents. ... So, friend don"t hear anything prefer that today. You hear concern on the component of progressives in this nation that justice Stevens and also the various other liberals are more likely to leave the court quickly than any type of of the conservative are, but I think we"ve come a long method since the 1930s, once that discussion was made so forcefully by Franklin Roosevelt."