Today’s A1 is the an outcome of a far an ext democratic and organic procedure than the one in ar when I landed on The times in 1978.



In an initiative to shed more light on how we work, The times is running a series of short write-ups explaining some of our journalistic practices. Read much more from this collection here.

You are watching: Front page editorial new york times

When I began at The brand-new York times in 1978, the newsroom to be a smoky, masculine dominion and the front-page conference was organized promptly at 5:30 p.m. Roughly a tiny table in the executive, management editor’s office.

Only the most an elderly editors were enabled to attend and also pitch their stories, and their fear as the hour approached to be palpable.

By midafternoon, it to be not unusual to listen the crash of the nationwide editor kicking a workdesk or slamming his phone down in frustration. Invariably, the reporter the end in the field couldn’t be discovered as the deadline neared, and the editor would have to get in the meeting far less all set than he would have actually liked.


The front-page meeting was a place where the newsroom’s ideal minds would pick the day’s most vital stories. But it was likewise a ar where careers to be made and sidelined.

It would take me year to acquire into that room, at first just to watch the prodding and questioning that went on, often with humiliating consequences for the editor who offered a story that was not deemed all set for publication.

It was hard not to it is in impressed by the intellectual firepower in the room. But it to be also difficult to view gray-haired adult literally hiding their hands under the table for this reason no one can see the they to be shaking as they talked.

A lot has readjusted since then. Today’s front page is the an outcome of a far an ext democratic and organic process. Because that one thing, the newsroom’s power is no longer focused exclusively on the deadlines of a push run. Stories and also slide shows, videos and interactive graphics are among the features going increase on the internet all day long.

There space “news meetings” at 9:30 a.m. And 4:30 p.m., where frequently 40 come 50 world sit around on modular furniture inside a glass-box room clearly shows to lot of the newsroom.


Washington editors, who when weren’t even permitted to speak, now beam in on a large TV screen, as perform editors based overseas. In these meetings, the is program to hear native sections the rarely have front-page candidates. Nowadays they are looking for “home page” time — one ever-evolving 24-hour formula that enables far much more stories to be showcased — and promoted in newsletters and also on our society media accounts.

For the most part, the front-page decisions room hashed the end throughout the day, never far out the alignment with those being produced the web, though there is a different front-page meeting at 3 p.m. Over there the last calls on stories are made (until something brand-new happens and the page needs to be remade). But much of the focus of that meeting is ~ above looking in ~ the obtainable photos and also designing the page. The style will dictate the dimension of headlines, leave editors little room to maneuver — unlike the much more flexible, and also fluid, procedure for the web. Often the title on the publish story understood the most essential of the job is in a narrow column, enabling only six or 7 words — not even fifty percent a tweet. (This gained us into trouble recently, once the need for a very short front-page publish headline led to one that lacked adequate context.)

Though in some methods the front-page decisions have actually become secondary in today’s 24-hour news cycle, countless reporters and also editors tho measure your success by how numerous of their story land there.

It is still a tradition in the newsroom come commemorate a reporter’s an initial front-page story v a metal plate of the page provided by our regional plant. (So far, no one seems satisfied v a display grab.)

The species of story that show up on the prior page have also readjusted mightily end the years. In the 1980s, federal government announcements, ceremonial meetings in between world leaders and also stories based on newly exit reports often overcame the page, together did images of mayors and also businessmen stand behind lecterns.

Since then, the definition of essential news has actually pushed into new areas. Analysis, lifestyle and also original reporting began to edge the end yearly stories about the Macy’s parade and an especially hot or particularly cold job in brand-new York. (Yes, together a young reporter ns wrote countless parade and weather stories.)

The changes were frequently distressing to the old guard. Once I was called National editor in 2005, a retired regulating editor who had once take away an interest in mine career took me out to having lunch to celebrate. However he can not avoid talking about what he witnessed happening at the paper.


How, that asked, can a story around how part parents in America to be trying come mimic the toilet training behavior used in foreign nations have make its way onto the prior page? “That is a topic for the format section!” he railed.

I couldn’t have actually disagreed more. Someplace in the people there is a 7-month-old baby who doesn’t need diapers in ~ night? That needs to interest just around anybody that has ever before had a child. But trying come breach the boundaries was not necessarily a good thing for her career, either.

Dean Baquet, the executive, management editor that The new York Times, counts himself lucky to have survived his decision in 1997, once he was national editor, to offer a story for A1 about teenagers who, fearing AIDS, were engaging in more oral sex.

See more: Ga Sec Of State Election Results, Georgia Secretary Of State Election Results

The room walk silent, Mr. Baquet recalls. The assistant regulating editor running the conference that day gradually let his head drop until his forehead fight the table. The story did eventually make its means into the paper, but not ~ above the front page.

Today, Mr. Baquet notes, the story wouldn’t raise one eyebrow. “By today’s standards,” he says, “it reads prefer a scientific research story.”