A federal court in Florida has actually ruled that it is unconstitutional for schools to half transgender college student from utilizing the restroom the matches their sex identity. Judges the the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit announced top top Friday the they space affirming a reduced court"s ruling on the matter since "a windy school may not punish its student for gender nonconformity."


The case was centered around Drew Adams, a 19-year-old previous student that Allen D. Nease High college in Ponte Vedra, Florida. Adams, that is transgender, offered the boys" restroom in ~ Nease High School, and also did therefore without any issues till an anonymous report was made, according to Lambda Legal. After the report, he to be told by school officials the he would just be enabled to use gender-neutral restrooms.

You are watching: Gender neutral bathrooms in high schools

Adams functioned with Lambda Legal come sue the school board in June 2017. The U.S. District Court for the middle District of Florida, a commonwealth court in Jacksonville, ruled in Adams favor in 2018, but Adams" college board appealed the decision critical year.


Y’all- The 11th circuit court of appeals said trans rights!! https://t.co/5O8wAzXgn2

— Andrew Adams 🏳️‍🌈✨🛡 (

"The institution Board"s restroom policy, as applied to Mr. Adams, singled him the end for various treatment because of his transgender status," the judges ruled on Friday. "A publicly school might not punish its student for gender nonconformity. Neither may a public school injury transgender students by developing arbitrary, separate rules for your restroom use. The proof at psychological confirms the Mr. Adams endured both this indignities."


The judges claimed that the colleges board did not uphold the 14th Amendment, which assures equal rights, and also Title IX, i m sorry bans sex distinguish in education.

CBS News reached out come the St. Johns County college District because that comment. The district has actually not yet responded.

According to Lambda Legal, this situation was the an initial in the nation to walk to trial around a transgender student"s appropriate to equal accessibility to restrooms.

See more: Stay Healthy At Home With These Free Workout Channels On Spectrum 2020

Tara Borelli, an lawyer at Lambda Legal, said that the court"s affirmation sent out a clear article "that schools need to treat transgender students with the same dignity and also respect as any type of other student."


"The trial court to be correct once it ruled the the legislation requires that attracted Adams be treated choose every various other boy and be allowed to use the boys" restroom," Borelli said. "We room glad the court saw the college board"s policy as unjust and discriminatory, and also affirmed the innate dignity and worth the transgender students."

Adams claimed he"s happy to view justice prevail "after spending almost my whole high college career fighting for same treatment."

"High college is hard enough without having actually your institution separate friend from her peers and also mark you together inferior," Adams said. "I expect this decision helps save various other transgender student from having actually to go with that painful and also humiliating experience."

In 2016, then-President Obama mandated that public schools allow transgender students to use the restrooms that align with their sex identity. After acquisition office in 2017, president Trumprescinded those orders.