You are watching: Girl texts guy to kill himself
Defendant Michelle Carter listens come testimony in ~ Taunton ar Court in Taunton, Mass., June 8, 2017.Charles Krupa / AP file
WASHINGTON — The supreme Court claimed Monday it would certainly not take it up one appeal brought by Michelle Carter, the young woman who motivated her boyfriend, through texts and phone calls, to death himself.
The court"s refuse to take the case leaves her conviction intact.
The Carter instance attracted worldwide attention and was the subject of a 2019 HBO documentary, "I Love You, now Die: The commonwealth V. Michelle Carter."
The court decreased to decision whether she involuntary manslaughter conviction violated the very first Amendment guarantee of totally free speech due to the fact that it was based specifically on words that she texted or spoke. She was sentenced to 15 month in jail.
In July 2014, 18-year-old Conrad Roy III the Massachusetts parked his truck and also filled it v carbon monoxide, killing self after several failed suicide attempts.
Evidence at her trial verified that Carter, that was 50 miles away in Plainville, sent out text messages in the job leading up to the suicide, encouraging him to go ahead v his plan, and spoke to him twice on the phone call the work he took his own life.
She later told a friend that he became frightened in ~ one allude and climbed the end of the truck, yet that she told that on the phone to get earlier in. The attempt judge stated that statement and also her failure to contact 911 or summon help were an essential facts supporting her conviction.
Her lawyers called the supreme Court that she can not be judge based solely on the native she texted or spoke — or failure to text or speak.
"Carter neither detailed Roy through the means of his fatality nor physically participated in his suicide," the lawyers said. They included that the Massachusetts courts listed no guidance on how to identify when a person"s words overcome the line and become criminal conduct.
See more: Everyone Is Now Dumber For Having Listened To It, Billy Madison (1995)
Prosecutors stated that after ~ at first trying come discourage that from suicide, Carter began a systematic campaign of coercion, preying ~ above Roy"s insecurities. She taunted him the he would deliberately fail again to kill himself, repeatedly urging the "just to perform it" and also that "the time (was) right."
Her conviction, the state said, was consistent with a long developed exception come the an initial Amendment because that "speech integral to criminal conduct."
If friend or who you know is in crisis, speak to the national Suicide avoidance Lifeline at 800-273-8255, text house to 741741 or visit SpeakingOfSuicide.com/resources for additional resources.
Pete Williams is one NBC News correspondent who covers the justice Department and also the can be fried Court, based in Washington.