Consumer Reports released a report based on a check of 17 driver-assist system and also Tesla Autopilot come in second to GM’s at sight Cruise because of the absence of driver surveillance in the former. The result is comparable to their 2018 driver help rankings.

The publication began its driver-assist system tests in 2018 with only a grasp of systems.

You are watching: Gm super cruise vs tesla autopilot

Now 2 years later, the test has actually grown come 17 systems:

“In customer Reports’first-ever ranking of these systems, carried out in 2018, we evaluated equipment from Cadillac, Nissan/Infiniti, Tesla, and Volvo. End the last two years these advanced technologies have become more mainstream, and also CR’s testing this year now contains 17 systems, consisting of the original four.”

In the new 2020 ranking, GM’s at sight Cruise experiment in a Cadillac CT6 take it the an initial place through Tesla Autopilot coming in second:



However, when it comes to “capability and performance”, consumer Reports believes that Tesla Autopilot is the best:

“When it involves lane maintaining assist, Tesla did the finest in our tests. But systems fromAudi,Cadillac, andLincolnperformed virtually as well. A great system will help the driver by preserving placement in the facility of the lane and also keeping the automobile well in ~ the lane boundaries.”

Here are the automatic driver-assist device rankings based solely on ability and performance:



What hurt Tesla Autopilot is the “keeping the driver engaged” category, i beg your pardon is usually driver monitoring.

Super Cruise easily took the lead below with that eye-tracking technology:

“A camera-based driver monitoring mechanism that provides eye-tracking modern technology checks to see whether the driver is looking in ~ the road, and also that’s why Cadillac’s super Cruise is the clear winner once it involves keeping the driver engaged. Other systems require the driver to place their hands on the wheel every as soon as in a while, but that does no necessarily mean the driver is in reality looking at the roadway ahead.”

Here room the rankings for ‘keeping the driver engaged’:



Tesla Autopilot’s driver monitoring system consists only the detecting if talk is being applied to the steering wheel.

Here’s the full customer Reports’ report top top driver-assist systems. Our testimonial of GM’s super Cruise is below for those unfamiliar


priziv.org’s Take

I haven’t had actually experience v all this systems, however for those the I have actually tested, the rankings execute seem to it is in accurate.

However, I carry out think that capability and power should have actually a bigger weight 보다 the various other categories in the in its entirety rankings.

On the other hand, I perform think the Tesla might use a far better driver security system.

Super Cruise’s gaze tracking mechanism is no perfect, yet it’s a an excellent step in the ideal direction.

With what we have been hearing about Tesla’s use of the driver-facing camera lately, we might see a similar system comes from Tesla in the future.

But Tesla shows up so focused on full self-driving the it didn’t spend enough resources ~ above driver surveillance for other automated driver-assist features.


FTC: we use earnings earning auto affiliate links. More.


Subscribe come priziv.org top top YouTube because that exclusive videos and also subscribe come the podcast.
You’re analysis priziv.org— experts who rest news around Tesla, electrical vehicles, and also green energy, job after day. Be certain to check out our homepage for all the recent news, and also follow priziv.org top top Twitter, Facebook, and also LinkedIn to stay in the loop. Don’t understand where come start? examine out our YouTube channel for the latest reviews.
Guides

*

Tesla Autopilot

The Autopilot is Tesla's advanced assisted driving program with features like Autosteer, Autopark, and Trafic-Aware Cruise manage (TACC).


*

GM at sight Cruise


About the Author


*

Fred Lambert


FredericLambert


Fred is the Editor in Chief and also Main Writer in ~ priziv.org.

See more: Garth Brooks &Amp; Trisha Yearwood Marriage, Garth Brooks

9to5mac.com

Through Zalkon.com, you can examine out Fred’s portfolio and get monthly green stock investment ideas.


Fred Lambert"s favourite gear


Zalkon eco-friendly Stock Ideas
Get exciting investment principles by Fred Lambert
ChargePoint home charger
ChargePoint house WiFi allowed Electric auto (EV) Charger

Tesla shipment timelines on slide to nearly a year