On Wednesday, speaker of the home Nancy Pelosi urged president Donald trump card to delay his reserved State that the Union speech to congress on January 29 because of security pertains to related come the partial government shutdown.

You are watching: Speaker pelosi urges state of the union delay over security concerns

As that Wednesday afternoon, there wasn’t one official solution from the White House. However the request did have people looking increase the customs and also processes related to the State that the Union attend to referenced by Pelosi in her letter.

In she letter, Pelosi stated that she had actually invited president Trump on January 3, 2019, to appear at the traditional event that has constitutional ties. “The constitution calls because that the chairman to ‘from time to time give to the Congress details of the State the the Union,’” Pelosi said, and also that for a long duration of time the President had actually submitted the speech together a written report. As result of “hamstrung” executive branch departments affected by the partial shutdown, Pelosi said associated security concerns forced she to asking the chairman to work with she “to determine another perfect date ~ the government has reopened because that this address” or to submit the resolve in writing.

Pelosi is introduce to the Constitution’s short article II, section 3 states in component that the president “shall from time come time offer to the Congress info of the State of the Union, and also recommend to their consideration such procedures as he shall referee necessary and also expedient; the may, on extraordinary Occasions, convene both Houses, or one of two people of them.”

In our interactive Constitution, scholars wilhelm P. Marshall and also Saikrishna B. Prakash agreed the “the chairman must administer information top top the ‘State the the Union’ native ‘time come time.’ This appears to need the president to share information with Congress.”

It is frequently understood the the later component of the passage, around the President’s ability to convene conference on “extraordinary occasions,” is usually regarded the presidential power to lug Congress back in session during a recess or adjournment. The Justice department website consists of an opinion indigenous Assistant Attorney basic George T. Washington indigenous 1947 about President harry Truman’s requests for Congress to resolve domestic legislation during an adjournment, after ~ Senator Robert Taft apparently contested the constitutionality of Truman’s requests. “The President has actually the power, under post II, ar 3 that the Constitution, to contact a distinct session of the Congress during the present adjournment,” Washington concluded. The last together session to be on July 26, 1948 after Truman authorize a presidential proclamation convening Congress.

While the is unsure if president Trump could compel congress to convene a joint meeting to listen his State the the Union speech throughout a congressional session, chairman Ronald Reagan did hold-up his 1986 State the the Union speech, i beg your pardon was scheduled on the same day as the Challenger disaster.

But the custom due to the fact that 1913 has been for the president to appear at a share session of Congress because that the State of the Union speech, uneven the chairman is in first year the his an initial term or concluding his last term.

Before 1913, President thomas Jefferson collection the prior criterion of sending a created report to Congress rather of do a personal appearance at Congress. Jefferson assumed the idea that a chairman addressing Congress was “monarchical.” (Presidents George Washington and John Adams had made State the the Union speeches in person.) Woodrow Wilson had actually been crucial of the Jefferson precedent in his academic writings and also he experienced the State the the Union speech as a tool to breakthrough his very own policies.

Wilson is “widely credited with expanding the limit of the annual message, transforming it from a report on the tasks of the executive, management departments right into a device to draw widespread attention to the plans he supported,” the conference Research company said in a January 2019 report about the State that the Union tradition.

In Wilson’s time, the occasion was dubbed the annual Message and also it ended up being officially recognized as State of the Union resolve in 1947. In 1965, the speech became a prime-time nationwide event during the lindon Johnson administration.

There were also reports top top Wednesday that Pelosi said reporters the President trump could constantly deliver the State the the Union decided at the White House, which would appear to it is in first. House majority Leader Steny Hoyer additionally told CNN that he assumed the letter native Pelosi meant the State that the Union to be cancelled.

See more: The First 100 Days Of President Trump 'S First 100 Days, Trump'S 100

But offered the letter’s wording, that is uncertain what would happen if the chairman insisted on offering the traditional speech to conference on January 29. In any type of event, that is clear under post II, ar 3 that the president does have actually the ability to tell Congress around the State the the Union in a means he look at fit. And likewise there is the implied duty because that the chairman to report top top the “State the the Union.”

Scott Bomboy is the editor in chef of the national Constitution Center.

Filed Under: Congress, Presidency, Separation that Powers, write-up I, section 5, article II, ar 3